Dog training is full of rules. They’re passed down like secret recipes from trainer to trainer, generation to generation – and often followed without question.

You’ve probably heard some of these classics:

  • “The dog always heels on your left side.”
  • “You should always end on a good note.”

They sound solid, don’t they? Like ancient wisdom carved in stone. But here’s the thing: traditions sometimes hang around long after their sell-by date. It’s not that they’re bad – just that they may not always fit your dog, your lifestyle, or even basic common sense anymore.

So, let’s roll up our sleeves, grab some treats, and dig into a couple of these “golden rules” of training – where they came from, why they made sense once upon a time, and whether they still hold up when you’re standing in your local park with a clicker in hand and a squirrel in sight.

So, “Heel on the left”?

Ah, the famous left-side heel — the dog-training equivalent of “because that’s how it’s always been done.”

So… why the left?

Let’s travel back a few centuries. You’re a soldier or a nobleman (lucky you!) walking through the countryside with your sword on your left hip. Since most people were right-handed, you’d draw your sword with your right hand — and you definitely didn’t want to accidentally stab your faithful companion while doing it.

Hence, your dog went on the left. Problem solved, dog unharmed, sword still ready for business.

Fast-forward a few hundred years, and the same idea stuck around for hunters with shotguns – dogs on the left, gun in the right hand, fewer singed tails. Then came the military and police dog traditions. Before long, obedience competitions decided: “Yep, left is standard. It’s consistent.”

And just like that, a centuries-old sword-carrying tradition became a rule people still quote in the village hall dog training class on a Tuesday night.

But does it make sense today?

Well… probably not for most of us. Unless you’re training your Cockerpoo for medieval combat, the left-side heel is more historical artifact than practical rule.

Here’s what actually makes sense:

  • If walking your dog on the left puts them next to traffic — switch sides!
  • If you’re left-handed — switch sides!
  • If your dog prefers one side or needs a different position for medical or physical reasons – switch sides!
  • And guess what? You can teach your dog to heel on both sides. In fact, doing so makes them more flexible and mentally engaged.

Tradition is sometimes nice. But your dog’s safety, comfort, and enjoyment? Way nicer.

What about “End on a good note”?

This one’s a fan favourite in training circles: “Always end the session on a good note.” The idea makes sense in theory. You want the dog to finish the session feeling successful, confident, and happy.

But let’s pause for a moment. What if – hear me out – your dog actually loves training?

If that’s the case, ending the session at all might actually be the opposite of a good note!

It’s like someone ending your game of Christmas charades with the family halfway through because they think you’ve had “enough fun.” (OK, that may in itself be a fantasy!)

When a dog is enjoying themselves, stopping can actually be a tiny punishment — a negative one, at that (removing something good). So maybe the rule isn’t as black and white as it sounds.

So, when do I stop a training session? I usually stop for one of two reasons:

  1. When the rate of reinforcement drops. If I notice I’m clicking and treating less often, that’s a red flag. It means fatigue or frustration is creeping in. My doggo might be slowing down, losing focus, or just getting mentally full. That’s my cue to stop before things unravel.
  2. When my dog makes a mistake.

Yep. Controversial, I know! But if my dog is experienced enough to understand the game, I sometimes end right after a mistake. Why? Because it adds a little “cliffhanger” – like ending an episode on a plot twist. My dog comes back next time eager to fix it because the impact of taking away her training fun was significant. (Thank you to the very clever Jo Hill for that one.)

Before you gasp, remember: this only works if training is already fun, safe, and positive. My dogs aren’t sulking in a corner about it — they’re raring to go next time.

Should you toss the rule out completely?  Not at all. It’s not about throwing the baby out with the bathwater (or the tennis ball out with the chew toy). The key is to understand the “why” behind the rule — and then decide whether it still makes sense for you and your dog.

If your dog finds training in any way stressful or uncertain (and you are working on changing that), yes – end on something easy and upbeat.

If your dog is gleefully obsessed with training, it’s fine to stop after a mistake or when you spot diminishing returns.

Either way, the goal isn’t to follow a script – it’s to read the dog in front of you.

🐾 The Bigger Picture: Question Everything (Kindly)

Dog training, like many traditions, has inherited a lot of rules that came from practical origins – but not all of them survive the logic test in today’s world.

Every now and then, it’s healthy to ask yourself:

  • Why am I doing this?
  • Is it helpful, or just habitual?
  • Does it make sense for this particular dog, in this particular context?

Because the truth is: good dog training isn’t about following commandments carved into stone tablets. It’s about curiosity, observation, and adaptability.

Your dog doesn’t care about 19th-century military parade standards. They care about how you make them feel, how you communicate, and how fun it is to work with you.

So keep questioning, keep learning, and if anyone tells you “you must do it this way,” feel free to smile and say, “Maybe… but let’s see if there’s a better way.”

👉 My final thought

The best trainers – with the happiest dogs – are the ones who keep asking questions.

Tradition can guide you, but your dog will always give you the best answers.

About Sarah Whitehead

Sarah Whitehead MSc is a Certified Clinical Animal Behaviourist, international lecturer, author and specialist in canine and feline body language, with more than 35 years’ experience in animal behaviour and training. She is particularly known for helping owners and professionals recognise the subtle signals that reveal how dogs are feeling before behaviour escalates.

Sarah’s flagship Learn to Talk Dog programmes explore canine body language, facial expression and dog-to-dog communication in depth, helping learners move beyond broad labels such as “friendly”, “stubborn” or “aggressive” and understand what an individual dog is actually communicating.

Sarah’s Socialisation in Adolescence webinar provides further learning specifically on the developmental changes that occur during adolescence and how these can influence a young dog’s social behaviour and responses to the world.

created with by jessica lynn design
web development by carolyn sheltraw
photography by Amanda Clarke Photography

[ays_quiz id="2"]